How odd...
Why would you insult this guy for his English when you could just as easily have said "Sorry, but you have to be a member. We highly encourage and appreciate community involvement. If you see 1up server violations please help us keep a clean server by posting them here
http://www.1upclan.info/forum/index.php?board=27.0."
Seems to me this could have been an opportunity to have an active member do positive things for this community. Not sure if I simply don't see your greater vision Evil or if you are deficient in both tact and social graces. I know if I was this poster I would probably avoid these forums and similarly find another place to play.
Here is something to think about...
As I write this there are over 1000 active servers and probably under 200 players playing them. Wow, more servers than players! It is easier to groom a regular player than it is to find a new one. 1up has the talent, creativity, resources and infrastructure to have very populated and admired servers... I would put a little more thought into thinking of ways not to **** that up.
Regards,
Lucky